Great moments in opera: Madama Butterfly

April 29, 2012

Puccini’s Madama Butterfly is one of the most popular operas in the repertory, consistently ranking in the top 10 most frequently performed works in the world’s opera houses (though it is only Puccini’s third most popular work, ranking below both La boheme and Tosca!). There is much to like about it: a central character whose faith and fidelity win our admiration even as her misplaced trust brings about her ruin, a touch of Japanese exoticism, and a gorgeous score. The opera premiered in 1904, and was revised several times before assuming its current form in 1907.

Lieutenant Pinkerton is a US Navy man who takes a wife — Butterfly — during an extended stay in Nagasaki. They conceive a child together, but Pinkerton departs soon afterward. The heart of the drama turns on Butterfly’s faithful and patient waiting for his return, which endures for years before being crushed by Pinkerton’s return in the company of his American wife.

The highlight of the first Act is the love duet for Butterfly and Pinkerton, Vogliatemi bene (Love me well). All is well at this point in the story, and the duet is ravishing. It is sung in this concert excerpt by Roberto Alagna and Angela Gheorghiu, with subtitles:

In Act II we have the opera’s musical high point: Butterfly’s heartbreaking aria Un bel di (One beautiful day), in which she dreams of the day when she shall see Pinkerton’s ship return to the harbour, and she shall once again see his face. The great Renata Tebaldi sings it in this clip, without subtitles, but they are hardly necessary in this case:

Pinkerton does return to Nagasaki toward the end of Act II, but in Act III Butterfly learns that he has forsaken her. Retreating into a private room, she takes her family’s ceremonial knife and sings Con onor muore (To die with honour). Blindfolding her child, she stabs herself and collapses on the floor just as Pinkerton rushes in. The finale is sung here by Patricia Racette in a 2009 production from the Met, with English subtitles.

9 Responses to “Great moments in opera: Madama Butterfly

  1. Janet Says:

    Craig, Have you ever seen My Geisha with Shirley McClaine?

    I’m going to listen to these while I work, although it’s rare for me to listen to opera.


  2. cburrell Says:

    No, I have never heard it (and, to be honest, never heard of it!). I do believe that, for me, Shirley McClaine’s being in something is a deterrent. Is it good?

  3. Janet Says:

    It’s a movie about making a movie of M. Butterfly. SM is an actress whose husband, played by Yves Montand, is the director of the film. She disguises herself as a geisha to audition for the role of Butterfly. I think it starts out as a joke, but she gets the part and it goes on from there. I remember liking the movie, but it’s been a really long time since I saw it, so I don’t know. I put it on my Netflix queue right before I saw this post.

    It’s not SM’s usual role, i. e. sexy office kitten, etc.


  4. Janet Says:

    I hope I recover from that puppet kid before bedtime. I’m thinking that this is traditional a Japanese puppet, but it’s kind of freaky in this context.


  5. Janet Says:

    I watched part of My Geisha last night. Not very good.


  6. cburrell Says:

    Pity. A disappointing movie is such a disappointment: two hours of life gone! Well, thanks for the report. I’ll scratch that one off the list.

  7. Janet Says:

    Well, I only watched about an hour, so there is that to be thankful for.


  8. cburrell Says:

    It must not have been very good at all. I try to be careful about what movies I start watching, but once started I almost always see them through. Books too. I have squandered many an hour in that fashion.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: